Richard Corbett: Why a progressive vote is vital in the 2009 European elections

There are at least three very good reasons why it is essential for Labour to prevail this summer against the forces of reaction and bigotry

by Tribune Web Editor
Friday, January 16th, 2009

There are at least three very good reasons why it is essential for Labour to prevail this summer against the forces of reaction and bigotry

JUNE’S European parliamentary elections are crucial on at least three counts: maintaining Labour’s comeback as we approach the next general election, avoiding the horrendous prospect of the British National Party gaining its first ever parliamentarians under the proportional electoral system, and ensuring a large contingent of socialist MEPs in the European Parliament ,which now has the decisive say on European legislation.

European elections tend to be a mid-term opportunity to kick the Government – whoever is in power. Turnout tends to be low and the xenophobic right may have a disproportionate influence. There is also the risk of electors being “bought” by big spenders. In 2004, the UK Independence Party spent more than the three main parties put together on its nationwide billboard campaign. But the tide of public opinion may be turning against Euroscepticism. UKIP failed miserably to inflame public opinion against the Treaty of Lisbon. On the contrary, there is a growing realisation that the EU is a necessary tool we must use to our advantage. If Labour puts a forceful case in a well-run campaign, we can win against the divided Tories and various Eurosceptics.

The BNP threat should be a powerful motivating factor for the decent majority to vote to keep the fascists out. With a proportional system, the BNP could get a seat with as little as 8.5 per cent of the vote in the North-West or 11 per cent in Yorkshire, the West or East Midlands. BNP MEPs would have not just the prestige and legitimacy of elected parliamentary office, but the resources in terms of staff and finance that go with it. They will link up with other fascist groups in Europe. This must be avoided at all costs.

The European Parliament is no longer a mere talking shop.  It has the decisive say on European legislation, the adoption of which requires its approval. The strength of the Socialist Group in the European Parliament should be a vital interest to those who seek progressive outcomes on issues such as climate change, fair trade, consumer protection, energy, fairness at the workplace, and regulating multinational companies.

In the field of social protection and workplace rights, Labour MEPs have achieved a number of victories against opposition from the Conservatives, UKIP and the Liberal Democrats. The strength and unity of the Socialist Group means we can seek a fairer deal on the Working Time Directive. We secured equal treatment for temporary and agency workers and a greatly improved Works Council Directive. The common manifesto of the Party of European Socialists includes a demand for legislation to close the legal loopholes in the Posted Workers Directive that led to the Laval, Rüffert and Luxembourg cases where the European Court of Justice deemed that the right of trade unions to organise and negotiate collective agreements was outstripped by the right of establishment.

These achievements and commitments are bitterly opposed by our opponents. UKIP MEP Godfrey Bloom even took to the airwaves over Christmas to call for the abolition of the national minimum wage, adding: “If I want to employ somebody at £4 an hour, that’s my business”. Meanwhile, the Tories want to turn back the clock and take Britain out of the Social Chapter, which our Labour Government took us into soon after the 1997 general election. Opt-out would be a disaster for workers’ rights in Britain – millions would lose the right to paid holiday and maternity pay. We would have the least protected workers in Europe. Rather than taking Britain’s workplace rights back a generation, we have a chance to increase the social dimension of Europe.

Of course, Europe has next to nothing to say on the National Health Service, education, taxation, pensions, local government, housing and most of the gut issues that determine national elections. But on the environment, consumer protection and workplace rights, we have to fight and win our political battles at European level. That’s why the European elections will be vital.

Richard Corbett is Labour MEP for Yorkshire and the Humber

The only place you can read all of Tribune's articles as soon as they are published is in the magazine. To find out more about subscribing from as little as £19, click here.

About The Author

  • John

    Richard, your argument that the EU Parliament is somehow democratic is frankly boring. You know full well that it is a democratic shambles. There is no direct connection between the Parliament and the citizens, no mandate, no responsible government. The Parliament does not even possess the right to initiate its own legislation. Even one of the few powers that the Parliament had, the right of review of the Commission budget was carefully and democratically undermined in the agreement of 2000 when it was agreed that certain documents of the Commission exposing the economic chaos that embodies the EU, will not be made public when exercising this power. In fact, even when the whole Santer Commission was compelled to resign over corruption, the Parliament could not even pass a censure motion. Stop selling us a lemon! Why not be honest and admit that the Westminster system is far superior to this hopeless construction that you claim to faithfully support. Sooner of later people will be motivated to protest against your elitist construction and you will be brought back to reality.

  • John

    Richard, your argument that the EU Parliament is somehow democratic is frankly boring. You know full well that it is a democratic shambles. There is no direct connection between the Parliament and the citizens, no mandate, no responsible government. The Parliament does not even possess the right to initiate its own legislation. Even one of the few powers that the Parliament had, the right of review of the Commission budget was carefully and democratically undermined in the agreement of 2000 when it was agreed that certain documents of the Commission exposing the economic chaos that embodies the EU, will not be made public when exercising this power. In fact, even when the whole Santer Commission was compelled to resign over corruption, the Parliament could not even pass a censure motion. Stop selling us a lemon! Why not be honest and admit that the Westminster system is far superior to this hopeless construction that you claim to faithfully support. Sooner of later people will be motivated to protest against your elitist construction and you will be brought back to reality.

  • Steve fowler

    Richard face it, your party and you! are finished and no one wants you round anymore so stop trying to make your party and yourself look good when you are dead in the water now.

    Don’t bother telling us about the how good the EU is for Britain when it is not good for us now cause the public see’s right through your lies now and don’t care what you have to say.

    Oh by the way prepear to have damn good kicking in the Euro elections when the voters turn to UKIP.

  • Steve fowler

    Richard face it, your party and you! are finished and no one wants you round anymore so stop trying to make your party and yourself look good when you are dead in the water now.

    Don’t bother telling us about the how good the EU is for Britain when it is not good for us now cause the public see’s right through your lies now and don’t care what you have to say.

    Oh by the way prepear to have damn good kicking in the Euro elections when the voters turn to UKIP.

  • Michael Heaver

    Being stuck in an inwards-looking anti-democratic European bloc is not progressive. The USSR failed. Richard must have bashed his head stumbling out of his limo, a limo paid for courtesy of Britain’s taxpayers.

    Those who support international co-operation and friendship on a global scale rather than a European one should show the EU nationalists like Richard Corbett and the racist BNP just what they think by voting UKIP.

  • Michael Heaver

    Being stuck in an inwards-looking anti-democratic European bloc is not progressive. The USSR failed. Richard must have bashed his head stumbling out of his limo, a limo paid for courtesy of Britain’s taxpayers.

    Those who support international co-operation and friendship on a global scale rather than a European one should show the EU nationalists like Richard Corbett and the racist BNP just what they think by voting UKIP.

  • Christian Mansell

    Progressive!!! European centralisation of power is not progressive… it is backward. It is time you were brought to account Richard. Were you also one of the MEPs who voted against the Feb 08 motion that the European Parliament would respect the June 08 Irish vote no matter the outcome. I think you were…

  • Christian Mansell

    Progressive!!! European centralisation of power is not progressive… it is backward. It is time you were brought to account Richard. Were you also one of the MEPs who voted against the Feb 08 motion that the European Parliament would respect the June 08 Irish vote no matter the outcome. I think you were…

  • David Jones

    “…the horrendous prospect of the British National Party gaining its first ever parliamentarians under the proportional electoral system…” – a typical comment from a totalitarian lefty, who appears to ignore DEMOCRACY, the sort who have sold us down the river. Go away Corbett.

  • David Jones

    “…the horrendous prospect of the British National Party gaining its first ever parliamentarians under the proportional electoral system…” – a typical comment from a totalitarian lefty, who appears to ignore DEMOCRACY, the sort who have sold us down the river. Go away Corbett.

  • Pingback: European Elections 2009 - Page 3

  • Sarah

    Keeping the fascists out, eh Richard? How about we start with Labour, who didn’t give the people a referendum on membership of the EU?

    Labour has destroyed this country. And the people will vote you OUT. Where you belong.

  • Sarah

    Keeping the fascists out, eh Richard? How about we start with Labour, who didn’t give the people a referendum on membership of the EU?

    Labour has destroyed this country. And the people will vote you OUT. Where you belong.

  • http://www.paulstott.typepad.com Paul Stott

    If I want to vote progressively in the Euro elections, how could I possibly vote Labour?

    It is ironic that new Labour, having done so much to create the vacuum in working class communities that the BNP wish to fill, then have the cheek to turn round and ask people to vote to keep those same fascists out!

    Sorry Richard, people are not as daft as you think they are.

  • http://www.paulstott.typepad.com Paul Stott

    If I want to vote progressively in the Euro elections, how could I possibly vote Labour?

    It is ironic that new Labour, having done so much to create the vacuum in working class communities that the BNP wish to fill, then have the cheek to turn round and ask people to vote to keep those same fascists out!

    Sorry Richard, people are not as daft as you think they are.

  • David Rogerson

    So after UKIP beat labour what do you think about eurosceptism now