‘Beware Roman Empire union’, TUC is warned

British trade unions were warned at the TUC congress to be aware of international mergers following claims that attempts by an American “Roman Empire” union to raid other organisations’ members on a massive scale threatens to undermine the labour movement in the United States.

by Tribune Web Editor
Friday, September 18th, 2009

by Chris McLaughlin

British trade unions were warned at the TUC congress to be aware of international mergers following claims that attempts by an American “Roman Empire” union to raid other organisations’ members on a massive scale threatens to undermine the labour movement in the United States.

Delegates were told that the Service Employers International Union, which under the leadership of Andy Stern broke up the 50th anniversary of the AFL-CIO by leading 4.6 million workers out of the organisation, has used underhand and unconstitutional methods to poach members.

Debbie Anderson, international officer of the hotels and gaming union Unite Here, told a fringe meeting organised by the GMB that the SEIU’s philosophy was to turn the labour movement into a “corporate friendly, top-down body with little or no membership involvement and on a path that has done great damage to the labour movement”.

Mr Stern has built the 1.8 million-strong SEIU into the fastest growing union in the US, forming the hub of a federation representing six million workers, including drivers, food workers, carpenters, hotel workers, labourers, janitors and health care workers.

After initial increases in the low wage sectors, workers are signed up to “partnerships” with companies which severely restrict their rights to operate freely as trade unionists.

Ms Anderson said that the hostility deployed in campaign tactics by  SEIU were “truly astonishing”. She accused the union of using funds raised by Unite Here to contact its own members in a negative campaign to persuade them to switch.

Leaflets were sent to members’ home addresses and cold-calling telephone campaigns were deployed in industrial sectors not represented by SEIU, which has a low membership reach in its own jurisdiction.

One leaflet, sent to Unite Here’s hotel sector members, was in the form of a “Do Not Disturb” sign hung on a bedroom door to insinuate that Unite Here was not interested in getting a fair deal for its members. Other tactics, according to Ms Anderson, have included smear campaigns, personal home visits, website attacks and the hiring of union-busting consultants.

The SEIU has been widely condemned by US union leaders. GMB leader Paul Kenny told the meeting that his union had been approached by SEIU several years ago with an offer of a “blank cheque” to help the union out of its then financial troubles.

The offer was turned down because the conditions would have given the SEIU the right effectively to take over the union.

The only place you can read all of Tribune's articles as soon as they are published is in the magazine. To find out more about subscribing from as little as £19, click here.

About The Author

  • JR MacClure

    Your article would have more credibility if you got the facts right. It is the Service Employees International Union and it doesn’t have anything like 4.6 million members and certainly didn’t 4 years ago. The membership is said to be a bit over 2 million. They have taken union organization to people normally ignored by the AFL-CIO. Anyone at the AFL-CIO who complains about other unions climbing into bed with management should look at THEMSELVES first.

    But you need to get your facts straight.

  • JR MacClure

    Your article would have more credibility if you got the facts right. It is the Service Employees International Union and it doesn’t have anything like 4.6 million members and certainly didn’t 4 years ago. The membership is said to be a bit over 2 million. They have taken union organization to people normally ignored by the AFL-CIO. Anyone at the AFL-CIO who complains about other unions climbing into bed with management should look at THEMSELVES first.

    But you need to get your facts straight.

  • ASPA

    This article seems to have generated some debate on a couple of other sites, first here:
    http://unisonactive.blogspot.com/2009/09/anti-seiu-campaign-politics-of-envy-fed_21.html

    and then a reply here:
    http://labourmovementtruth.blogspot.com/

    Wonder what is going to come of this debate?

  • ASPA

    This article seems to have generated some debate on a couple of other sites, first here:
    http://unisonactive.blogspot.com/2009/09/anti-seiu-campaign-politics-of-envy-fed_21.html

    and then a reply here:
    http://labourmovementtruth.blogspot.com/

    Wonder what is going to come of this debate?

  • Sam

    I suppose the 4.6 million members refers to the Change to Win coalition that SEIU formed with some other unions to break away from the AFL-CIO. The split was about a lot of things – but it certainly was not about organising as far as I can see. You couldn’t have spoted the difference betwen the organising strategies of either in truth. But thats the SEIU line. But since you mention it do you know which workers are CTW organising now that they werent organising when they were in AFL-CIO? And what do you think about those CTW unions who are now re-joining AFL-CIO. Are they wrong to do so?

  • Sam

    I suppose the 4.6 million members refers to the Change to Win coalition that SEIU formed with some other unions to break away from the AFL-CIO. The split was about a lot of things – but it certainly was not about organising as far as I can see. You couldn’t have spoted the difference betwen the organising strategies of either in truth. But thats the SEIU line. But since you mention it do you know which workers are CTW organising now that they werent organising when they were in AFL-CIO? And what do you think about those CTW unions who are now re-joining AFL-CIO. Are they wrong to do so?

  • Union Supporter

    The SEIU of years ago was a good, progressive union. Under Stern’s leadership its focus appears to be headed off the streets and into the boardroom. In an era when working people need democratic and strong unions more than ever, it’s frightening that a union once in the vanguard of change can so easily be subverted into one that appears ready to lay down for the bosses.
    Even many of SEIU’s leaders don’t agree with Stern. However, to disagree publicly means potential loss of your jobs – look at NUHW in California.

  • Union Supporter

    The SEIU of years ago was a good, progressive union. Under Stern’s leadership its focus appears to be headed off the streets and into the boardroom. In an era when working people need democratic and strong unions more than ever, it’s frightening that a union once in the vanguard of change can so easily be subverted into one that appears ready to lay down for the bosses.
    Even many of SEIU’s leaders don’t agree with Stern. However, to disagree publicly means potential loss of your jobs – look at NUHW in California.

  • ScruffM31

    I dont know anything about this SEIU crowd – and even less about the AFLCIO – and couldn’t care less to be honest. In my union UNISON the only people SEIU seem to want to take union organising to is the CEO’s of Sodexho and Compass. This scandal is a big deal for us – we are growing as a union, our members are under daily attack and we need renew our democracy and make sure the members control the beaurocrasy. SEIU henchmen like Crosby (Apparently just back from turning the LMHU union in Australia into a SEIU lackey)will just help our leadership deliver us up to the Tories in my view.

  • ScruffM31

    I dont know anything about this SEIU crowd – and even less about the AFLCIO – and couldn’t care less to be honest. In my union UNISON the only people SEIU seem to want to take union organising to is the CEO’s of Sodexho and Compass. This scandal is a big deal for us – we are growing as a union, our members are under daily attack and we need renew our democracy and make sure the members control the beaurocrasy. SEIU henchmen like Crosby (Apparently just back from turning the LMHU union in Australia into a SEIU lackey)will just help our leadership deliver us up to the Tories in my view.

  • ASPA

    ScruffM31 – Unison members might want to be careful, there’s some secret 3 companies project that SEIU are working on with Unison:

    http://unisonactive.blogspot.com/2009/09/organising-union-debate-on-our.html

  • ASPA

    ScruffM31 – Unison members might want to be careful, there’s some secret 3 companies project that SEIU are working on with Unison:

    http://unisonactive.blogspot.com/2009/09/organising-union-debate-on-our.html

blog comments powered by Disqus